
Toxic Shame: Understanding Shame, Self-Criticism & Self-Worth | Core Life Psychology Copy
Understanding toxic shame, self-criticism, perfectionism and low self-worth, including how shame develops and how therapy can help you develop a different relationship with yourself.
Shame is a deeply human emotion. Most of us experience it at times — perhaps after making a mistake, saying something we regret, or feeling that we have fallen short of our own or someone else’s expectations.
But for some people, shame is much more pervasive. Rather than being connected to something we have done, it becomes connected to who we believe we are.
We may begin to experience ourselves as inadequate, defective, unworthy, foolish, inferior or unlovable. This can become what is often described as toxic shame: a deeply embedded sense that something is fundamentally wrong with us.
Toxic shame can influence the way we see ourselves, our relationships, our work and the choices we make. It can also sit beneath patterns such as perfectionism, people-pleasing, self-criticism, anxiety and difficulty trusting ourselves.
What is toxic shame?
Shame is different from simply recognizing that we have done something wrong.
Healthy or adaptive shame can help us recognize when our behaviour has gone against our values or has affected another person. We may feel embarrassed, regretful or uncomfortable, learn from the experience and then return to our usual sense of self.
Toxic shame is different.
Instead of thinking:
“I did something wrong.”
the experience becomes:
“There is something wrong with me.”
The focus shifts from behaviour to identity.
We may become preoccupied with our perceived shortcomings — our appearance, abilities, relationships, thoughts, feelings or past actions. Even relatively small interactions can become the subject of intense self-scrutiny.
After a conversation, for example, we might replay everything we said, wondering whether we sounded foolish, awkward or inadequate. A small mistake can feel disproportionately significant. Rather than being able to acknowledge the mistake and move on, we may experience a powerful sense of personal failure.
When shame becomes intense, the body can also react strongly. We may feel exposed, vulnerable or overwhelmed and have an urge to withdraw, hide or retreat from further judgement.
Over time, chronic shame can become exhausting. We may develop ways of managing or avoiding the feeling without necessarily recognizing that shame is driving these patterns.
Shame as a common human experience
Most people experience some degree of shame from time to time.
We might feel embarrassed after behaving in a way we regret, or experience a temporary drop in confidence when we compare ourselves unfavourably with someone else. We might wake after a night out and feel embarrassed about something we did or said.
These experiences can be uncomfortable without fundamentally changing how we see ourselves.
Shame can also have an adaptive function. It can help us recognize when we have behaved in ways that are inconsistent with our values or have hurt someone else. It can motivate us to repair relationships, take responsibility and change our behaviour.
The difficulty arises when shame becomes chronic, excessive or disconnected from what we have actually done.
For some people, shame becomes much more generalized. Rather than being about a particular action, it can feel as though their whole self is somehow wrong or unworthy.
This can create a painful cycle of comparison, rumination and self-judgement.
How shame develops
Although shame is experienced internally, it often has a relational history.
Our sense of ourselves develops through our relationships with the people around us, particularly during childhood. As children grow and become increasingly aware of themselves and other people's responses, experiences of acceptance, rejection, criticism and connection begin to shape their developing sense of self.
A child has fundamental needs for connection, love, safety and acceptance. When these needs are repeatedly met with criticism, withdrawal, hostility or indifference, the child may begin to make sense of the experience in terms of themselves.
Instead of:
“Something is happening that I don't understand.”
the emotional conclusion may become:
“There must be something wrong with me.”
Shame can develop through obvious criticism or hostility. A child may be called stupid for making a mistake, become the target of an angry reaction, or experience repeated disapproval.
But shame does not always develop through dramatic or overt experiences.
It can also emerge through repeated subtle interactions — disapproving looks, changes in tone, withdrawal of affection, emotional absence or a lack of responsiveness. Over time, these experiences can communicate that particular feelings, needs or aspects of the self are unacceptable.
The child then begins to develop ways of managing this experience.
They may learn to suppress certain feelings, become highly compliant, stop asking for what they need, or work hard to maintain connection and approval.
In this way, what later looks like a personality trait or behavioural pattern may have originally served an important protective function.
Shame and the strategies we develop
When shame becomes painful, it makes sense that we would try to protect ourselves from experiencing it.
People can develop many different strategies in response to shame.
These can include:
perfectionism
people-pleasing
self-criticism
self-deprecation
self-doubt
anxiety
overworking
excessive striving
difficulty expressing needs
avoiding situations where we might be judged
constantly monitoring how we behave around others
There can be a persistent sense of needing to get things right.
We may become highly alert to what we say, how we behave and how other people might be responding to us. Beneath this can be a fear of being exposed, found inadequate or revealed as somehow not good enough.
For some people, the solution becomes achievement.
If I perform well enough, work hard enough, look good enough or become successful enough, perhaps I will finally feel acceptable.
But the relief is often temporary.
The underlying shame remains, and the person has to keep striving to maintain their sense of worth.
When shame is hidden behind other emotions
Shame does not always look like shame.
Sometimes it is covered by other emotions or behaviours.
Anger, for example, can sometimes protect against feelings of vulnerability, inadequacy or exposure. Rather than experiencing the painful feeling underneath, we become angry with another person or critical of their behaviour.
In relationships, this can create repetitive patterns where anger becomes more visible while the underlying hurt, fear or shame remains hidden.
Shame can also be displaced through criticism of other people. If we are intensely uncomfortable with our own perceived inadequacies, focusing on the shortcomings of others can temporarily move attention away from ourselves.
Other forms of over-compensation can include developing a particularly confident or dominant persona, excessive work, achievement or other behaviours that help keep vulnerable feelings out of awareness.
These strategies can be understandable attempts to protect ourselves. But over time they can also restrict our ability to be vulnerable, connected and authentic.
Shame and the world around us
Shame is not created solely within families or individual relationships.
The wider culture can also communicate powerful messages about how we are supposed to look, behave and live.
We can be told that we are too loud, too quiet, too thin, too large, too ambitious, not ambitious enough, too emotional or not emotional enough.
Social media, advertising, cultural expectations, family and other social systems can all contribute to an environment in which comparison becomes almost constant.
When we are continually exposed to messages about who we should be, it can become difficult to hear our own internal sense of what matters to us.
We may begin organizing our lives around other people's expectations rather than our own values.
How toxic shame can affect life now
Chronic shame can have a significant impact on how we move through the world.
If we expect criticism or rejection, we may become highly vigilant about other people's reactions. We might hesitate before speaking, avoid asking for help, or hold ourselves back from opportunities where there is a possibility of failure or judgement.
Perfectionism can become a way of trying to prevent shame.
People-pleasing can become a way of maintaining connection and avoiding rejection.
Self-criticism can feel like a way of staying one step ahead of other people's criticism.
Anxiety can become closely connected to the need to anticipate and prevent anything that might expose us as inadequate.
These strategies may have developed for understandable reasons. But they can eventually become restrictive.
Life can become organized around avoiding the experience of shame rather than moving towards the things we genuinely value.
Beginning to work with shame
For someone who has lived with chronic shame for a long time, developing a different relationship with themselves can take time.
It is rarely as simple as telling ourselves to “be more confident” or “think positively”.
Shame often operates at both a cognitive and emotional level. We may intellectually understand that we are worthy and yet still experience a deep, visceral sense of inadequacy.
This is one reason that simply arguing with shame-based thoughts is not always enough.
An important first step is developing greater awareness.
Notice when shame appears.
Notice what happens in your body.
Notice the thoughts that accompany it.
Notice what you feel compelled to do next — hide, withdraw, apologize, over-explain, please someone, work harder or criticize yourself.
Over time, becoming familiar with these patterns can create some space between the experience of shame and the actions that usually follow.
Developing self-compassion
Working with shame also involves developing a different way of relating to ourselves.
This does not mean ignoring mistakes or avoiding responsibility.
Rather, it means beginning to recognize that many of our patterns may have developed as attempts to cope with difficult experiences, relationships or circumstances.
We can acknowledge mistakes without condemning ourselves.
We can learn from the past without continually punishing ourselves for it.
We can begin to ask:
How would I speak to myself if I were speaking to someone I cared about?
Self-compassion can involve learning to treat ourselves with greater kindness at a physical, emotional and cognitive level.
It can also involve recognizing the difference between responsibility and self-condemnation.
Moving away from shame-based patterns
There are many small ways we can begin to challenge shame.
We might:
notice when we are becoming self-critical
question whether other people are actually judging us, or whether we are anticipating judgement
allow ourselves to make mistakes without turning them into statements about our worth
practice saying no when we genuinely mean no
reduce unnecessary people-pleasing
notice when perfectionism is taking over
spend time with people who recognize and value us
become more aware of relationships that consistently leave us feeling diminished
reconnect with interests, values and goals that feel personally meaningful
acknowledge small achievements rather than dismissing them
practise allowing ourselves to experience healthy pride
consider how we would speak to our younger selves with greater kindness
Sometimes the work is also about becoming more willing to hear our own voice.
When we have spent years adapting to other people's expectations, it can take time to discover what we actually want, feel and value.
Therapy for toxic shame
Working through longstanding shame can be difficult to do alone.
Therapy can provide a space to slow down and explore the patterns that have developed around shame — including self-criticism, perfectionism, people-pleasing, anxiety, relationship difficulties and a persistent sense of not being good enough.
Rather than simply trying to eliminate uncomfortable feelings, therapy can help us understand what these patterns have been protecting us from and begin developing different ways of responding.
This can involve becoming more aware of the emotional and relational experiences underlying shame, working with defences and gradually developing a more accepting relationship with ourselves.
For some people, this process also involves coming to terms with painful experiences from the past and developing a greater capacity for self-forgiveness.
Change is often gradual.
The aim is not to become a person who never experiences shame. Shame is part of being human.
Rather, it is to become less governed by it.
To be able to make mistakes without collapsing into self-condemnation. To be able to tolerate vulnerability without immediately retreating. To make choices based more on your own values and less on the fear of judgement.
And, over time, to develop a sense that your worth does not have to be continually earned.
If shame has become a persistent part of how you see yourself
If you find yourself caught in cycles of self-criticism, perfectionism, people-pleasing or feeling fundamentally inadequate, therapy can provide a place to understand these patterns and begin to relate to yourself differently.
At Core Life Psychology, I work with adults experiencing longstanding emotional and relational patterns, including shame, self-criticism, anxiety and difficulties with self-worth.
Recent posts
Related Articles
Your go-to source for mental health insights, tools, and advice.




